Uncategorized

On Communism

The Communist Manifesto is one of the most assigned books in economics, and I would argue it’s at the heart of most of our problems. Not because it is assigned, but because the people assigning it and the kids reading it have applied no logic to its claims.

Before we dig too deeply into what Marx proposed, we need to understand something about every society throughout history and around the world. It makes no difference where you look; there will always be more people with less than those with more.

Marx wanted to end the conversation there, but I suggest we go a little deeper to uncover a truth that Socialists and Communists want to keep hidden. Marx used only two terms when discussing his economic system. The people with more of something (the Bourgeoisie) and the people with less of something (the Proletariat). But what he, and no Socialists, will ever discuss are the lines between those two things.

When I say, it isn’t fair because he makes more than I, can that ever be the end of the conversation? Shouldn’t someone step up and ask questions like, “Who am I comparing myself to?” If I sweep floors and he is the President of the company, should I be making what he makes? Does everyone in the company do the exact same job?

Or where someone says, “It isn’t fair because the owner gets to make all of the decisions while we do all of the work.” A question might be: do you know enough about the business to make decisions? There are plenty of people that just want to go to work, get paid, and not have to deal with the extra stress of making tough decisions.

But Marx never considered anything except that Capitalism must be bad and that his Socialist system would be fairer. He never asked a single tough question and never answered any that were put forward. I would even take the position that Marx was a very lazy man without the abilities that would have allowed those deeper discussions.

Marx discussed the unfairness between people, but he never drew a clear line. He never distinguished specifically how much you could have of your own before you were also considered an enemy. He did believe absolutely no one should own any property though. He never considered that if people didn’t own their property, the government would have to. But who would serve in the government, and why should they have the power to make decisions? This is why I said Marx was lazy; he never considered the tough questions, and it is for this very reason Communism and Socialism tend towards murder and destruction of their people.

The mere fact that so many schools discuss Marx as a philosopher who considered society’s tough questions, without any rhetoric asking whether those ideas are valid, shows how much our education system has deteriorated. Proof is easy to find; start asking these socialists questions and see how quickly they founder.

But before we declare the war won, we should take a look in the mirror at the system we support. Unbridled capitalism is equally fraught with perils. Marx was not wrong in all of his views of our system. People should be limited on their amount of capital they are allowed to possess before it starts to funnel into society. They should be restricted on how much land they can own and limit companies from buying other companies, with stiffer penalties to curb monopolies. But before those lines are drawn, serious discussions need to be had on where they lie.

All of this madness has a point, though, which I’ve touched on in previous articles. Without the ability to formulate questions that expose the truth, things like Marxism, Communism, and Socialism will continue to plague us. We should all take advantage of the next time we’re around one of these people to ask questions. Only a few will begin to expose the truth and set them on their heels, looking for the door.

By: Glenn Hancock. I can be reached at glennh@fastmail.com

Leave a Reply